Detecting language using up to the first 30 seconds. Use `--language` to specify the language
Detected language: English
[00:00.000 --> 00:05.000]  Welcome to the show. I was recently on a conference call during which a smart
[00:05.000 --> 00:10.360]  gentleman who's new to the subject of the income tax offered a rebuttal to
[00:10.360 --> 00:14.880]  remarks about wage withholding statutes only being applicable to certain
[00:14.880 --> 00:19.080]  government entities and not to private sector companies like the one for which
[00:19.080 --> 00:24.360]  you work or work for at some point in your life. Because he's a smart guy I
[00:24.360 --> 00:28.680]  want to share with you his rebuttal to the point I often make that the law
[00:28.680 --> 00:33.240]  limits payroll withholding to government entities. After you hear what the law
[00:33.240 --> 00:38.680]  says then his rebuttal and my response let me know what you think in the
[00:38.680 --> 00:41.120]  comments.
[00:43.360 --> 00:48.920]  The Dr. Reality Vodcast with Dave Champion.
[00:54.560 --> 00:58.640]  Let's start with this. As you know if you've been following me for any length
[00:58.640 --> 01:01.920]  of time I'm the author of Income Tax Shattering the Mist, the best-selling
[01:01.920 --> 01:06.440]  book in the country that proves to the American people that Congress has never
[01:06.440 --> 01:11.320]  imposed the income tax on ordinary hard-working Americans like you. I say
[01:11.320 --> 01:16.400]  proves to the American people for two reasons. First is that nothing in the
[01:16.400 --> 01:21.720]  book is me telling you what tax law says. Everything in the book is what the
[01:21.720 --> 01:26.800]  government says about income tax and what the government has said in the law
[01:26.800 --> 01:31.760]  rather than in its propaganda and disinformation is that the income tax
[01:31.760 --> 01:39.760]  does not apply to you. The government has said consistently for 112 years that the
[01:39.760 --> 01:44.000]  income tax does not apply to you. The second reason I say income tax
[01:44.000 --> 01:47.480]  Shattering the Mist proves that the income tax has never been imposed on
[01:47.480 --> 01:52.720]  ordinary hard-working Americans is every single reader since its publication 15
[01:52.720 --> 01:56.920]  years ago knows with absolute certainty when they close the final page that the
[01:56.920 --> 02:01.720]  income tax has not been imposed on them. They know it with absolute certainty
[02:01.720 --> 02:06.480]  because as I mentioned income tax Shattering the Mist isn't what I say
[02:06.480 --> 02:11.400]  about the income tax it's what the government has said consistently for 112
[02:11.400 --> 02:17.520]  years without exception. With that as the backdrop in my 32 years of sharing the
[02:17.520 --> 02:21.800]  truth of the income tax with my fellow Americans I'd never before heard the
[02:21.840 --> 02:28.080]  rebuttal this one astute gentleman offered. Since I did not ask his consent
[02:28.080 --> 02:34.040]  to use his name today I'll simply refer to him as Frank. Let me lay out the scene
[02:34.040 --> 02:39.200]  so you'll understand just how astute his remark was. The discussion was about
[02:39.200 --> 02:44.280]  chapter 24 of the tax code which is entitled collection of income tax at
[02:44.280 --> 02:50.240]  source on wages. That title is just a statutory way of saying payroll
[02:50.240 --> 02:57.800]  withholding. The first two sections of chapter 24 are 3401 and 3402. Let's start
[02:57.800 --> 03:02.960]  with 3402 because it is the command to deduct and withhold and reads as
[03:02.960 --> 03:08.360]  follows. Except as otherwise provided in this section every employer making
[03:08.360 --> 03:12.080]  payment of wages shall deduct and withhold upon such wages a tax
[03:12.080 --> 03:17.360]  determined in accordance with blah blah blah. The group's attention then turned
[03:17.360 --> 03:24.360]  to section 3401 which contains the definitions that control who is to
[03:24.360 --> 03:29.480]  engage in payroll withholding and upon whom it is to be performed. The first
[03:29.480 --> 03:35.600]  subsection examined was how Congress defined the term employee for the purpose
[03:35.600 --> 03:41.240]  of payroll withholding. That's found at 3401 C and reads for the purpose of this
[03:41.240 --> 03:45.800]  chapter the term employee includes an officer employee or elected official of
[03:45.800 --> 03:49.520]  the United States a state or any political subdivision thereof or the
[03:49.520 --> 03:53.000]  District of Columbia or any agency or instrumentality of any one or more of
[03:53.000 --> 03:58.480]  the foregoing. The term employee also includes an officer of a corporation. For
[03:58.480 --> 04:01.640]  today's presentation I'm not going to speak to the final sentence except to
[04:01.640 --> 04:06.320]  mention that it doesn't mean an officer of a private corporation. Let's read the
[04:06.320 --> 04:10.760]  first sentence again. For the purpose of this chapter the term employee includes
[04:10.760 --> 04:15.200]  an officer employee or elected official of the United States a state or any
[04:15.200 --> 04:19.400]  political subdivision thereof or the District of Columbia or any agency or
[04:19.400 --> 04:24.240]  instrumentality of any one or more of the foregoing. For 30 years I've been
[04:24.240 --> 04:29.160]  asking people to explain how a definition that speaks exclusively of
[04:29.160 --> 04:35.060]  various government positions means people in the private sector. Not a
[04:35.060 --> 04:40.840]  single person has ever been able to answer that. Of course that's unsurprising
[04:40.840 --> 04:44.920]  because Congress did not intend that definition to embrace anyone in the
[04:44.920 --> 04:51.360]  private sector. The next definition examined was subsection D which defines
[04:51.360 --> 04:57.180]  the term employer for the purpose of payroll withholding. The interesting
[04:57.180 --> 05:01.960]  thing about this definition is the previous definition at which we looked
[05:01.960 --> 05:07.600]  employee actually establishes the meaning of employer. Let's read the
[05:07.600 --> 05:12.720]  definition and you'll see what I mean. 3401 D reads as follows. For the purposes
[05:12.720 --> 05:16.560]  of this chapter the term employer means the person for whom an individual
[05:16.560 --> 05:24.800]  performs or performed any service of whatever nature as the employee. In other
[05:24.800 --> 05:29.080]  words for the purpose of payroll withholding an employer is defined as an
[05:29.080 --> 05:35.840]  entity that employs the previously defined employees. Keeping in mind that
[05:35.840 --> 05:41.400]  the meaning of employer is controlled by the definition of employee let's read
[05:41.400 --> 05:47.520]  employee one more time. The term employee includes an officer, employee or
[05:47.520 --> 05:51.440]  elected official of the United States, a state or any political subdivision
[05:51.440 --> 05:55.560]  thereof or the District of Columbia or any agency or an instrumentality of any
[05:55.560 --> 06:06.000]  one or more of the foregoing. So whoever those employees work for is an employer
[06:06.000 --> 06:09.560]  for the purpose of payroll withholding. Pretty simple stuff once we will
[06:09.560 --> 06:15.520]  actually read what the law says. As a side note even for government employers
[06:15.520 --> 06:20.200]  from whom they are allowed to withhold is more narrow than these definitions
[06:20.200 --> 06:24.440]  may lead you to believe. As an example payroll withholding has nothing to do
[06:24.440 --> 06:27.440]  with American citizens but for that you'll have to read income tax
[06:27.440 --> 06:31.720]  shattering list to see all the connecting information. Before I move on
[06:31.720 --> 06:36.800]  if you enjoy being exposed to knowledge you will never get from the media and
[06:36.800 --> 06:40.520]  oftentimes from no other source than this channel please take a moment to
[06:40.520 --> 06:44.560]  subscribe and hit the like button so the algorithms will show this content to
[06:44.560 --> 06:50.240]  more people. Also for a limited time you can get free shipping on any of my books
[06:50.240 --> 06:53.760]  as long as income tax shattering the miss is included in the order simply use
[06:53.760 --> 06:58.160]  the code tariffs at checkout. I'll share that again at the end. Now back to the
[06:58.160 --> 07:03.280]  story. I just described the point to which the call had gotten when Frank
[07:03.360 --> 07:10.600]  chimed in with his question. He said that from his reading of chapter 24 there was
[07:10.600 --> 07:15.760]  no doubt in his mind it applies exclusively to government entities. Okay
[07:15.760 --> 07:24.120]  so far so good. But then he said we've been discussing this one chapter. Where's
[07:24.120 --> 07:28.820]  the other part of the law that requires payroll withholding from workers in the
[07:29.740 --> 07:36.060]  I liked his question because it showed he was thinking. Accepting pretty much
[07:36.060 --> 07:41.340]  anything uncritically is unwise in my opinion and this gentleman had done just
[07:41.340 --> 07:46.420]  the opposite. He listened carefully to the dialogue and applied critical
[07:46.420 --> 07:51.100]  thought to the issue. Having read US tax law for more than 30 years I decided I
[07:51.100 --> 07:55.400]  was the right guy to respond to his question so I jumped in. I began by
[07:56.360 --> 08:00.880]  seeing clearly the chapter 24 deals exclusively with wage withholding by
[08:00.880 --> 08:05.640]  government. I'm a big believer that people learn best by conducting their own
[08:05.640 --> 08:10.760]  research rather than being told by someone else what this or such is true.
[08:10.760 --> 08:15.600]  With that in mind I explained to Frank that I had been looking for the section
[08:15.600 --> 08:23.680]  he was asking about for 32 years and never found it. I went on to share with
[08:23.840 --> 08:28.680]  him that in the 112 years the income tax has been in existence tens of thousands
[08:28.680 --> 08:34.020]  of researchers have been looking for the section he'd asked about and no one has
[08:34.020 --> 08:39.200]  found it. I suggested that after 112 years of no one being able to find it
[08:39.200 --> 08:44.960]  perhaps he might be the guy to finally locate it. In short I didn't tell him
[08:44.960 --> 08:48.520]  such a section does not exist because that would require him to believe me and
[08:48.760 --> 08:54.360]  I never want anyone to take my word for anything. Instead I pointed out the
[08:54.360 --> 09:00.480]  section he was asking about has not been found in 112 years and invited him to
[09:00.480 --> 09:05.720]  prove thousands of legal researchers wrong. At that point Frank had two
[09:05.720 --> 09:10.920]  options. He can accept that if thousands of legal researchers have never found
[09:10.920 --> 09:17.880]  such a section it does not exist or he can do the research and discover
[09:17.880 --> 09:23.240]  for himself that it does not exist. Either option will get him to the truth
[09:23.240 --> 09:29.040]  which is that no law exists authorizing private sector companies to withhold
[09:29.040 --> 09:34.320]  anything from the pay of their workers. Does it not shock you that virtually
[09:34.320 --> 09:38.280]  every private business in America takes money out of the paychecks of their
[09:38.280 --> 09:45.640]  workers without a shred of legal authorization? I hope it does more than
[09:45.640 --> 09:51.680]  shock you. I hope it pisses you off because that's the proper response to
[09:51.680 --> 09:56.520]  businesses engaging in theft from the American people on a scale never
[09:56.520 --> 10:01.600]  imagined. While we're talking about mass theft of your property by American
[10:01.600 --> 10:05.760]  businesses in an upcoming presentation I'm going to share with you an audio
[10:05.760 --> 10:12.480]  recording of the reaction of a payroll expert after he read the sections we
[10:12.480 --> 10:20.760]  just discussed. It's not pretty. You'll see that he becomes defensive and
[10:20.760 --> 10:25.800]  downright nasty as soon as he reads the definitions. You'll also hear another
[10:25.800 --> 10:30.240]  person from that same company say that following the law is, and I'm quoting
[10:30.240 --> 10:37.280]  here, really bad advice. I'm not kidding. That audio will be a rare glimpse into
[10:37.280 --> 10:42.560]  how these thieves act when they see what the law actually says. I call them
[10:42.560 --> 10:46.880]  thieves because a person who isn't a thief would read the statutes we've
[10:46.880 --> 10:51.360]  been discussing and say, holy cow I've been doing this for years without
[10:51.360 --> 10:56.920]  knowing what the law says. Now that I know I'll stop withholding immediately.
[10:56.920 --> 11:03.880]  Instead of doing what an honest person would do they become defensive, angry, and
[11:04.280 --> 11:09.560]  aggressive. That's because even after they see that what they're doing is
[11:09.560 --> 11:18.960]  legally wrong they intend to continue stealing your property. As I said, thieves.
[11:18.960 --> 11:23.600]  I should also mention there's an attorney in Los Angeles who is now
[11:23.600 --> 11:29.360]  accepting clients to sue companies who are illegally withholding, which is all
[11:29.360 --> 11:33.680]  of them. I should also let you know that because I know what the law says I haven't
[11:33.680 --> 11:39.480]  filed an income tax return or paid a penny of income tax in 32 years. I'd like
[11:39.480 --> 11:47.920]  you to consider something using your intellect, your logic. Every tax law in
[11:47.920 --> 11:54.320]  existence contains a collection mechanism by which that tax is collected
[11:54.320 --> 12:02.200]  from those who owe it. Everyone. Zero exceptions. Now consider that there is no
[12:02.200 --> 12:05.200]  law authorizing private sector companies to withhold income tax from
[12:05.200 --> 12:11.840]  a worker's pay. Every law that imposes a tax includes a collection mechanism, but
[12:11.840 --> 12:17.360]  there is no law that allows income tax to be collected from working Americans.
[12:17.360 --> 12:21.760]  I'm going to repeat that not because you're stupid, but because most
[12:21.760 --> 12:26.440]  Americans have been so thoroughly brainwashed by government propaganda that
[12:26.440 --> 12:31.720]  their minds automatically reject simple rational statements that create a
[12:31.720 --> 12:39.800]  conflict with the propaganda they've believed for years. So try to suspend for
[12:39.800 --> 12:44.040]  a moment the belief created by decades of being bombarded with government
[12:44.040 --> 12:49.600]  propaganda. Perhaps as you're listening, pretend the subject is something other
[12:49.600 --> 12:53.440]  than income tax or maybe I'm talking about another country. Anything that
[12:53.440 --> 12:58.080]  allows you to mentally set aside the narrative that's been ingrained in you
[12:58.240 --> 13:06.960]  and just hear these statements objectively. Ready? Number one, every tax
[13:06.960 --> 13:11.880]  law in existence contains a collection mechanism to collect it from those who
[13:11.880 --> 13:19.320]  owe it. Number two, no law exists in the United States that permits anyone to
[13:19.320 --> 13:26.600]  take any tax out of the money you receive earning a living. Are you feeling
[13:26.600 --> 13:33.320]  a bit disconcerted like there has to be something else somewhere else? If you are,
[13:33.320 --> 13:38.320]  that's coming from the propaganda they've embedded in your head. I call
[13:38.320 --> 13:42.260]  that the Doctrine of Missing Parts and I've done a video on it. I'll put the
[13:42.260 --> 13:47.320]  link down in the notes. The Doctrine of Missing Parts is a subconscious reaction
[13:47.320 --> 13:53.560]  to hearing the truth about the income tax because the truth conflicts with the
[13:53.560 --> 14:00.640]  lie you've heard and believed your entire life. When a falsehood is
[14:00.640 --> 14:04.840]  thoroughly embedded in our brain, it can be really challenging to accept the
[14:04.840 --> 14:10.720]  truth. The reason for that is accepting the truth requires us to admit we were
[14:10.720 --> 14:19.760]  fooled. We were taken in by the lie and by the liars. It's okay to feel that
[14:19.760 --> 14:23.240]  emotional pushback. When I first heard the truth of the income tax more than
[14:23.240 --> 14:29.160]  30 years ago, I didn't instantly buy into it and the truth did conflict with
[14:29.160 --> 14:36.020]  what everyone had told me my entire life up until that moment. What I did not do
[14:36.020 --> 14:42.480]  and what I hope you won't do is I did not dismiss what I was being told because
[14:42.480 --> 14:48.640]  it conflicted with what was already in my head. Since both narratives could not
[14:48.640 --> 14:55.360]  be true, I wanted to know which one was the truth. In the early 90s, the internet
[14:55.360 --> 15:00.280]  was not a useful tool like it is today and there was no singular resource
[15:00.280 --> 15:04.320]  available on the subject as there is today. We'll get into that shortly. I
[15:04.320 --> 15:10.180]  spent almost two decades researching tax law in law libraries and working in
[15:10.180 --> 15:15.140]  conjunction with other researchers across the nation. The fruits of that
[15:15.140 --> 15:20.900]  research has been compiled for you in income tax shattering the miss. The
[15:20.900 --> 15:26.220]  mountains of incontrovertible evidence you'll find there convinces even the
[15:26.220 --> 15:30.780]  most ardent skeptic that the income tax does not apply to ordinary hard-working
[15:30.780 --> 15:36.860]  Americans. People have purchased income tax shattering the miss just to prove
[15:36.860 --> 15:42.140]  me wrong and they ended up seeing the truth. I know this because a number of
[15:42.140 --> 15:48.260]  them have emailed to tell me about it. Let me ask you a question. How many
[15:48.260 --> 15:55.460]  things do you believe the federal government lies about? I'm confident
[15:55.460 --> 16:03.860]  every lie you can think of is, at its core, about money or power. So ask
[16:03.860 --> 16:09.220]  yourself if it's possible the government is lying to you about the
[16:09.220 --> 16:15.500]  income tax which is all about money and power. The federal government has been
[16:15.500 --> 16:19.860]  lying to the American people about the income tax for at least 70 years. It's
[16:19.860 --> 16:26.540]  been lying about the income tax since before you were born. In other words, you
[16:26.540 --> 16:33.580]  were born into the matrix as was I and like me you can leave the matrix. All you
[16:33.580 --> 16:41.300]  need to do is read one book. Right now and for a limited time I'm offering free
[16:41.300 --> 16:46.780]  shipping on any order from my doctorreality.news website. If the order
[16:46.780 --> 16:51.260]  contains a copy of income tax shattering the miss, I'm going to suggest you
[16:51.260 --> 16:56.580]  purchase the four-pack containing income tax shattering the miss, the business
[16:56.580 --> 17:02.020]  guide to payroll withholding, the business handbook for forms W-9 1099 in
[17:02.060 --> 17:07.940]  U.S. person, and body science. The first reason to get the four-pack is the prices
[17:07.940 --> 17:12.100]  already deeply discounted from purchasing the four items individually.
[17:12.100 --> 17:17.100]  The second reason is that in addition to it being deeply discounted you get free
[17:17.100 --> 17:21.580]  shipping by using the code tariffs. Here's a quick overview of each item in
[17:21.580 --> 17:25.660]  the four-pack. Income tax shattering the miss. Yeah you already know what that's
[17:25.660 --> 17:29.580]  going to do for you. The business guide to payroll withholding is a 13-page item
[17:29.580 --> 17:34.580]  intended to help workers convey the truths we've been discussing today to
[17:34.580 --> 17:39.540]  the company for which they work in order to ask them to follow the law and stop
[17:39.540 --> 17:44.620]  withholding. Not everyone is articulate or can recall legal citations on the
[17:44.620 --> 17:48.100]  spur of the moment so I wrote the business guide to payroll withholding to
[17:48.100 --> 17:52.100]  help with that. It's also a great primer if you just want to wake anybody up to
[17:52.100 --> 17:58.340]  the truth of the income tax. The business handbook for forms W-9 1099 in U.S.
[17:58.340 --> 18:03.780]  person is also 13 pages and is intended to help self-employed people communicate
[18:03.780 --> 18:08.380]  to those with whom they do business why they are not required to furnish a form
[18:08.380 --> 18:13.980]  W-9 and why the person or entity paying them is not legally required and in fact
[18:13.980 --> 18:19.380]  is not legally permitted to file a form 1099. The handbook is also a great primer
[18:19.380 --> 18:23.780]  if you just want to wake someone up to the truth of the income tax. Body
[18:23.780 --> 18:29.380]  science is my groundbreaking work on human physiology that is the key to what
[18:29.380 --> 18:33.700]  so many people say they want right now which is to turn around the health of
[18:33.700 --> 18:39.420]  the American people. Sadly the vast majority of Americans prefer to get
[18:39.420 --> 18:44.820]  their views on nutritional physiology from a corrupt media rather than a
[18:44.820 --> 18:48.300]  physiologist who tears down the false establishment health narratives and
[18:48.300 --> 18:53.340]  gives you the science of getting and staying healthy presented in a way
[18:53.380 --> 18:57.900]  everyone can understand. If you're sincere about getting and staying
[18:57.900 --> 19:03.540]  healthy you need to read body science. I practice what I preach I adhere to
[19:03.540 --> 19:07.380]  everything you'll discover in body science and at 65 I'm as healthy as I
[19:07.380 --> 19:15.660]  was at 25. Perfect health no chronic diseases no big pharma products and I
[19:15.660 --> 19:21.220]  haven't been sick a day in years. During the COVID event I never wore a mask
[19:21.260 --> 19:26.060]  never social distanced shook hands with people hugged my friends lived life as I
[19:26.060 --> 19:32.300]  always had and never got COVID. That's how your immune system will operate if
[19:32.300 --> 19:39.820]  you follow what you learn in body science. So go to drreality.news
[19:39.820 --> 19:44.700]  and pick up income tax shattering the mess or the four-pack. Remember to use
[19:44.700 --> 19:49.220]  the coupon code tariffs to get free shipping on any order containing income
[19:50.220 --> 19:55.260]  Also purchasing any of my writings helps me to continue to be here for you with
[19:55.260 --> 19:59.300]  these revealing and thought-provoking presentations. Thank you for sharing your
[19:59.300 --> 20:03.620]  time with me today I hope you consider a time well spent